How to Choose an AI SEO Agency: 8 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

Category

Content

Posted on

Updated

Author

Daria Nikolaeva

SEO & AI Search

Clinic owner meeting with an AI SEO agency consultant

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Quick answer: A good AI SEO agency helps your business show up in both Google and AI answers, and proves it with honest tracking. Before you hire one, ask how they track AI mentions, what work they actually do each month, who you’ll talk to, and what happens if you want to leave. Walk away from anyone who guarantees ChatGPT will recommend you. Nobody can promise that.

The agency that promised the moon

Picture Rachel. She owns a physical therapy clinic. An agency calls her with an exciting pitch: “We guarantee you’ll be the number one recommendation in ChatGPT within 30 days.”

It sounds amazing. She signs a 12-month contract.

Month one: a report full of charts she doesn’t understand. Month three: the same. Month six: she asks ChatGPT about physical therapists in her town. She’s still not mentioned.

When she asks what they’ve been doing, the answer is vague. When she asks to cancel, she learns she’s locked in for six more months.

Rachel didn’t hire a bad agency because she wasn’t smart. She hired one because she didn’t know what questions to ask. Here they are.

1. “How do you track AI mentions?”

A good answer sounds like: “We track a set list of real buying questions across ChatGPT and Google’s AI answers every month. None of the questions include your business name.”

That last part matters. Of course AI knows you if someone types your name. The real test is whether AI recommends you to strangers.

2. “What will you actually do each month?”

You should hear specific tasks, like:

  • Writing pages that answer customer questions.

  • Getting you mentioned on trusted websites and “best of” lists.

  • Fixing technical problems on your site.

  • Improving your reviews and business listings.

If the answer is just “we optimize,” ask what that means.

3. “Do you do regular SEO too?”

You want a yes. AI tools often search the web before they answer. If you don’t show up in search, AI has a harder time finding you. Good agencies treat SEO and AI search as one job.

4. “Can you guarantee results?”

The honest answer is no. Nobody controls what AI says. An agency that guarantees a spot in ChatGPT is either guessing or not telling the truth.

What a good agency can promise: clear work, honest tracking and regular updates.

5. “Who will I talk to?”

Some agencies sell you with a senior expert, then hand you to someone brand new. Ask who will plan your work and who you’ll talk to each month.

6. “How do you report results?”

You should get reports you understand. Look for:

  • How often you’re mentioned compared to competitors.

  • Which questions you show up for.

  • What they did and what’s next.

A short video walkthrough or a call beats a 40-page PDF.

7. “What’s the contract?”

Long contracts aren’t always bad, but you should know what you’re signing. Ask:

  • How much notice do I need to give to cancel?

  • Do I own the content and pages you create?

  • What happens to my accounts if I leave?

You should own everything you pay for.

8. “Can I see an example?”

Ask for a sample report or a real (anonymous) example of their work. Real agencies have something to show. Watch out if all they have is screenshots of one lucky AI answer, since AI answers change every day.

Red flags to watch for

  • Guarantees of a top spot in ChatGPT.

  • Vague answers about the actual work.

  • No plan to track AI mentions.

  • You can’t own your content.

  • Pressure to sign today.

How much does an AI SEO agency cost?

It varies a lot. Small agencies and solo consultants often charge less than big firms. What matters more than price is what you get each month and whether you can see it working.

If an offer is much cheaper than everyone else’s, ask what’s missing.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between an AI SEO agency and a regular SEO agency?
A regular SEO agency focuses on Google rankings. An AI SEO agency also works on getting you mentioned and quoted in AI answers. The best ones do both.

How long until I see results?
Usually a few months. Be wary of anyone who promises results in days.

Can I do this myself instead?
You can do a lot yourself: clear pages, reviews and matching business details. Start with What Is AI Search Optimization? and Best AI Search Optimization Tools for Beginners.

Want to ask me these questions?

Please do. I’ll give you straight answers. See how I work on my AI search optimization page, or book a call.

Let’s talk about your next step.

Schedule a free 15-minute consultation with SOURCEsem. Tell us about your business, ask your questions, and get clarity on where to focus next.